Applying the Employment Allowance to every employee. The £10,500 offsets your business’s entire secondary Class 1 bill for the year, not each employee’s. It is drawn down payroll run by payroll run until it is used up or the tax year ends, whichever comes first. Work out gross NI across the whole payroll first, then take the allowance off once. The multi-employee view here shows the headroom left, which is the number that tells you what your next hire really costs.
Giving a sole-director company the allowance anyway. gov.uk is explicit: if your company has only one director, they must not be the only employee liable for secondary Class 1 National Insurance. A great many personal-service companies fail this test and are told by online calculators that they owe nothing. Tick the sole-director box here and the allowance switches off with the reason attached, rather than silently returning zero.
Treating the under-21, apprentice or veteran relief as unlimited. The 0% employer rate for categories M, H and V stops at the Upper Secondary Threshold of £50,270, after which the normal 15% resumes. An under-21 on £60,000 costs £1,459.50 in employer NI, not nothing. Freeport and Investment Zone reliefs cut out far earlier, at £25,000.
Thinking staff over State Pension age are free of NI. Category C removes the employee’s contribution only. The employer still pays 15% above the Secondary Threshold on exactly the same terms as category A. This asymmetry catches out employers who see “no National Insurance” on an older worker’s payslip and assume the saving is theirs too.
Carrying over the old £9,100 threshold or 13.8% rate. Both changed on 6 April 2025: the Secondary Threshold fell from £9,100 to £5,000 and the rate rose from 13.8% to 15%. Any figure copied from 2024/25 content overstates the threshold by £4,100 and understates the rate by 1.2 percentage points, which on a £30,000 salary is a £1,111 error in the employer’s favour. Check that whatever tool you use stamps the tax year on its answer.
Confusing the Apprenticeship Levy pay bill with NI-liable pay. The two bases are different. The pay bill includes earnings for under-21s and apprentices under 25 even though no employer NI may be due on them, and excludes benefits in kind charged to Class 1A along with the earnings of under-16s. Reusing your NI-able total as the pay bill will misstate the levy in both directions.
Charging the auto-enrolment minimum on full pay. The statutory 3% is charged on qualifying earnings — the slice between £6,240 and £50,270 — not on gross salary. On £30,000 that is £712.80, not £900, and on £60,000 it is £1,320.90 rather than £1,800 because the band is capped. Plenty of employers do use a more generous basis, so switch the basis here if yours pays on full salary.
Costing a director’s bonus as though it were an employee’s. A mid-year bonus paid to a director does not get the benefit of period-by-period thresholds the way an ordinary employee’s would, because a director is assessed across the whole year at once. Budget a director’s bonus at the full 15% from the first pound, and see the directors’ National Insurance question below for how the annual earnings period works.
Reading monthly and weekly thresholds as exact twelfths. HMRC publishes the Secondary Threshold as £96 a week and £417 a month alongside the £5,000 annual figure, and those are rounded rather than exact divisions. Real payroll charges period by period, so a monthly-paid employee’s NI for the year can land a few pounds either side of the annual calculation shown here. It is a rounding difference, not a modelling error, and it never reaches double figures on a normal salary.